The Creek

The Creek

At the base of the Picabo Hills, deep in the Wood River Valley aquifer, dozens of springs push upward, seeping across the surface of the land. The practical consequence of this ancient dance of glacial activity, precipitation, pressure, and time was the birth of a cold, clear waterway teeming with life. Here, consistent water temperatures, slow flows, and vegetation-lined banks have bred the perfect environment to sustain prolific insect hatches and large trout. This is not just any stream; it’s a destination, a Mecca of sorts that has captivated the imagination of anglers for over 100 years. Anglers in south-central Idaho have come to refer to this place simply as 'The Creek.'

Chasing a Drake hatch can feel a bit like sitting at a blackjack table. You read the signs, hope luck is on your side that day, and place an educated bet. Months of stormy weather preceding our journey to Silver Creek had tempered expectations to the point of guarded optimism, bordering on apathy each time the heavy gray sky let loose a deluge of rain. Nevertheless, anticipation was evident among a crew that included Fishpond photographer Cassie Bergman and local angler Harrison Clement. As a college student in Montana, Harrison had traversed the rivers of the West each spring in pursuit of these prolific hatches.

“It's like trying to catch lightning in a bottle. Doesn't come along every day, week, or month—just a precious few times each year. And when those spinners fall, it's downright overwhelming, a sight to behold. You can't slap a 'been there, done that' label on this one. Every time those bugs show up, it's like the first time, man,” he remarked on a call before we departed.

If, like us, you’re no stranger to life on the road punctuated by hushed conversations over a breakfast burrito, or an impromptu trip to a local shop to trade a six-pack for information, you know that relationships often make or break a gamble. South Central Idaho is home to a vibrant community of anglers—an energetic and youthful fellowship bound by a passion for untold stories and eager to share their knowledge with others who share a reverence for this special place.

Picabo Angler, Picabo, ID
Picabo Angler, Picabo, ID

A series of phone calls to local contacts and a visit to the nearest shop revealed cause for concern. Recent evening storms had kept bugs grounded, and the prospect of another loomed. However, that news did nothing to dim the enthusiasm of those we encountered throughout the day. Their excitement was palpable, a shared anticipation for the upcoming experience, even if our paths never crossed that evening on the water. As we arrived at Silver Creek, stormy weather greeted us, painting a beautiful yet unassuming landscape.

We set out on foot to the river under foreboding skies, searching for some semblance of predictability among ever-changing conditions. Harrison carefully traversed the banks of the creek, studying the behavior of the fish below, while Cassie immersed herself in the tall grass, capturing naturals as they calmly perched, prepared for a grand departure that might never arrive and wholly unaffected by her presence.

Ephemera simulans (Brown Drakes)
Ephemera simulans (Brown Drakes)

By late afternoon, we had settled in a spot on the bank to observe and to wait. The first few Brown Drakes darted out from the safety of the brush, compelled by 250 million years of evolution. More followed but were quickly met by a rain storm carried by the gusting wind. As quickly as they had arrived, the Drakes had disappeared. But, on that warm June evening as the sun began its slow descent toward the horizon, the sky cleared, casting fiery pastel hues across the Snake River Plain. The wind calmed, and the rain followed suit.

A few more bugs gracefully ascended, then ten, then twenty. Swiftly, a hundred joined them over the water, and within minutes, the sky transformed into what must have been millions. The substantial size of the Brown Drake cast a darkness in the air. Initially appearing chaotic and haphazard in flight, a closer observation reveals intricate patterns. In flight, the Drake ascends a few feet, then drops repeatedly, progressing upstream in harmony with the water's path. In the soft brilliance of the setting sun, each mayfly's translucent wings were illuminated, creating a shimmering dance in the evening glow.

Amidst this grand performance of natural beauty, another unexpected event was underway. Ever the meticulous documentarian, Cassie had taken advantage of the lull in activity to journey back to camp to retrieve dinner. Hoping to enjoy a relaxing streamside meal, she prepared a piping hot bowl of pasta. The tranquility of the reprieve was short-lived. “I’m making my way back when I get a call from Harrison declaring ‘IT’S ON!’ Dinner in hand, I transitioned from a casual walk to an awkward run, juggling hot bowls of fettuccine, hoping I wouldn’t miss the main event. When I got to the river, I just dropped the food and jumped into the water, camera in hand,” she recalled later that night.

Surrounding us, dimples punctured the current and folded back on themselves, momentarily popping and roiling the tension of the water. For the uninitiated, you’d be excused for stumbling across the phenomenon and mistaking the river for a thermal hot spring, alive and bubbling, seemingly on the verge of boiling over. The dimples appeared, disappeared, and reappeared elsewhere, betraying the position of hundreds of trout frantically plucking away at the buffet above. Affectionately referred to as the ‘lightning round,’ these sunset shows typically last around 30-60 minutes. That evening, we were treated to the 'director’s cut' of nature's film, offering several hours of uninterrupted chaos as we adjusted our presentation and fly selection to accommodate the waning light.

As the lightning round subsided, we climbed out of the river, returning to the streamside meal of fettuccine and ice-cold beer that Cassie had left behind. The fishing and the catching were excellent, but to try to describe how it feels is to attempt to convey the ineffable. Like trying to hold water in your hands, it quickly slips away, leaving behind only the spirit of an immersive experience. It’s a revelation that generations of anglers uncover, then carefully salt away, understanding the joy that comes from discovering it organically. The echoes of the evening’s grand performance lingered, multiplied by the memory of notable fish brought to hand.

Chasing a hatch like this is more than just a gamble; it’s an intimate experience of the unpredictability of the outdoors. Now, as we embrace the new year, we look back, not just on one epic Drake Hatch, but on the sum of many adventures, big and small. What we do on the river is often a proxy for the rest of our lives. The same principles of curiosity, community, perseverance, and stewardship that can put you in the right place and time to intercept the Brown Drakes extend well beyond the river’s edge. We carry these lessons with us, knowing that the river, like life, is a constant flow of challenges and triumphs. Here’s to more adventures, and to the surprises they offer to those willing to seek them out.

Additional Stories

Continue Reading